$ (USD) 
First Valentine's Day Gifts : Thoughtful Ideas for New Relationships
By Ellie Dharamraj - 17th December 2025
The first Valentine's Day with a new partner is both exciting and a little daunting. Should you go all out with a grand romantic gesture or keep it simple and low-pressure? Finding the perfect balance between meaningful and appropriate can feel overwhelming, especially when you're trying to make a good impression without going overboard. Whether you've been dating for nearly a year or just started dating, we've rounded up thoughtful gift ideas for every stage of a new relationship, ensuring your first Valentine's Day is memorable for all the right reasons.
What do I gift on my first Valentine's Day?
Your first Valentine’s Day together is about setting the tone, so the best gifts feel thoughtful rather than overwhelming and show that you have really considered what this new chapter means. Whether you lean romantic, sentimental or playful, choosing something that reflects your connection will make the moment feel natural and memorable.
Grand Romantic Gestures
If you want to make a lasting impression, romantic gifts with a sense of occasion are a beautiful place to start. The Summer Nights Dried Flower Bouquet or the Luxury Pastel Dried Flower Bouquet offer a timeless alternative to fresh flowers and can be kept as part of your home décor long after Valentine’s Day has passed. Jewellery also feels especially meaningful for a first celebration, with the Adjustable Sterling Silver Double Heart Ring in Gold or Stainless Steel Magnetic Heart Pendant Necklace in Gold or the Stainless Steel Solid Heart Chain Bracelet in Gold symbolising your growing bond in a subtle yet heartfelt way.
Sentimental Keepsakes
Keepsakes are perfect if you love the idea of giving something your partner can treasure. A Personalised Natural Linen Jewellery Case or a Personalised Pink Velvet Bracelet Box adds a personal touch while being genuinely useful. The Lancaster & Gibbings Heart Photo Holder is ideal for displaying a favourite memory, while the Tiny Matchbox Love You Ceramic Heart Token offers a small but deeply thoughtful reminder of how you feel.
Fun and Lighthearted Ideas
Do I get a Valentine's Day gift for someone I just started dating?
If you have just started dating, a Valentine’s Day gift should feel thoughtful but easy-going, showing interest without putting too much pressure on the moment. Simple gestures often work best at this stage, such as the Dried Pink Daisy Bunch, which feels romantic without being over the top, or The Chocolate Gift Company Press For Champagne Truffles for a sweet treat that can be enjoyed together.
Personalised gifts can still work when they are kept subtle and practical. The Personalised Small Pink Ceramic Heart Trinket Dish is a lovely option that feels considered without being intense, while drinks like the 100ml Edmunds Cocktails Strawberry Daiquiri add a fun, shared experience. For something a little more refined, Personalised Gold Label Wine offers a thoughtful touch that remains relaxed and appropriate for a new relationship.
If you have just started dating, a Valentine’s Day gift can be a gentle way to show interest without placing too much weight on the occasion, and jewellery works particularly well when it is simple and understated. Pieces such as the Sterling Silver Knot Ring in Silver or the Adjustable Stainless Steel Wave Ring in Gold feel meaningful without being intense, while the Heart Chain Bracelet in Silver adds a subtle romantic touch that suits a new relationship and can be worn easily every day.
First Valentine's Day Gifts for Him
Your first Valentine’s Day together is a chance to show thought and care without going overboard, and gifts for him can balance meaning, usefulness and personality. Choosing something that reflects who he is will feel natural and considered, especially at the start of a relationship.
Sentimental Ideas
Sentimental gifts are ideal if you want to mark the occasion in a personal way. A Personalised Men’s Woven Leather Bracelet or a Personalised Stainless Steel Thick Band Ring in Gold offers a lasting reminder of your connection without feeling too intense. For something quietly meaningful, the Personalised Handwriting Leather Tag Keyring captures a moment or message in a way he can carry every day, while the Tiny Matchbox Ceramic Lobster Token adds a small but charming touch of affection.
Practical Gifts
Practical gifts work beautifully for a first Valentine’s Day, as they show thought while fitting easily into everyday life. The Men’s Personalised Embroidered Initials Wash Bag or the Personalised Men’s Leather Wallet and Keyring Gift Set in Tan combine usefulness with a personalised finish. For something more refined, the Sagaform Wine Carafe with Personalised Oak Stopper or Personalised Initial Edge Brushed Finish Round Cufflinks bring a sense of occasion that still feels appropriate.
Fun and Quirky Options
First Valentine's Day Gifts for Her
Your first Valentine’s Day together is a lovely opportunity to give something thoughtful that feels exciting rather than overwhelming. Gifts for her can be romantic, meaningful or simply fun, and the most important thing is choosing something that reflects her personality and the stage you are at as a couple.
Romantic Gifts
Romantic gifts are perfect for marking the occasion in a way that feels special without being too serious. The Tiny Red Hearts Bud Vase is a sweet decorative piece that works beautifully with a single flower or dried stems, while the Poetry of Love for Every Day of the Year Book offers a gentle way to share romantic moments throughout the year. Jewellery also makes a timeless choice, with the Personalised Birthstone Heart Locket Necklace in Gold or the Personalised Sterling Silver Family Names Large Heart Necklace adding a meaningful touch that feels both intimate and considered.
Sentimental Touches
If you want to give something she can treasure, sentimental gifts are a thoughtful option for a first Valentine’s Day. The Build Your Own Gift Hamper for Her allows you to create something personal without pressure, while the Pink Wildflower Sketch A Day Visual Journal encourages creativity and reflection. A keepsake, such as the Tiny Matchbox Ceramic Match Token, offers a small yet heartfelt reminder of your connection that can be kept close.
Playful Picks
Your first Valentine's Day gift doesn't have to be extravagant to make an impact. Thoughtfulness and effort are what truly count. Whether you opt for something more romantic, sentimental, or playful, the key is to choose a gift that reflects your relationship and makes them feel special.
Still looking for the perfect gift? Explore our Valentine's Day collection and find a meaningful gift to mark this exciting milestone in your relationship.
